If you prepare returns in Intuit ProConnect Tax, the premium tax credit is one of the places Check return gets loud. This page lists every Form 8962 and Form 1095-A diagnostic we could trigger on a 2025 test return, with the message as ProConnect prints it, what it actually means, and the input that cleared it. Every fix below was tested: we caused the diagnostic, made the change, ran Check return again and watched it go away.
Search this page for the ref number in your diagnostic (for example 42135). Screen names are as they appear in ProConnect Tax for tax year 2025. This site is not affiliated with Intuit.
Ref 42135: household income on line 3 is negative
Form 8962: Household income on line 3 must equal the total of line 2a, Modified AGI, and 2b, dependents' modified AGI, for efile purposes. If the total of lines 2a and 2b are negative, zero will print on line 3 and this return will need to filed as a conventional paper return.
What it means. Line 3 of Form 8962 is the taxpayer's modified AGI (line 2a) plus any dependents' modified AGI (line 2b). The 2025 instructions say to combine them even if one or both are negative, and to enter zero on line 3 if the total is below zero. The IRS e-file system requires line 3 to equal 2a plus 2b, so when the total is negative and line 3 shows zero, the return cannot be e-filed.
What usually causes it. A business or rental loss bigger than everything else on the return. On our test return, a Schedule C with $4,000 of receipts and $45,000 of expenses pushed AGI to negative $11,000.
How to clear it.
- If the loss is a typo (a misplaced digit, an expense entered twice), fix it where it was entered, here Income > Business Income (Sch C). Once line 2a plus 2b is zero or more, the diagnostic clears.
- If the loss is real, there is no input that clears it. The return has to be filed on paper, as the message says.
Why the credit may still be large. Household income below 100% of the federal poverty line usually means no premium tax credit. But the instructions make an exception when advance payments (APTC) were paid for at least one month, the marketplace estimated at enrollment that income would be at least 100% of the poverty line, nobody can claim the taxpayer as a dependent, and the taxpayer otherwise qualifies. That is why ProConnect still allowed the full credit on our test return. The exception does not apply if no APTC was paid, or if the taxpayer gave the marketplace incorrect information with intentional or reckless disregard for the facts.
Ref 42308: the 1095-A needs monthly amounts
This return is required to calculate the Premium Tax Credit and Reconciliation of Advance Payment of Premium Tax Credit using the Monthly Calculation. However, one or more Form 1095-A entries are missing monthly amounts in the input screen for "Form 1095-A - Health Insurance Marketplace Statement". To calculate the credit correctly, the monthly premium, SLCSP, and advance payment of premium credit must be entered on a monthly basis.
What it means. Form 8962 has two ways to figure the credit: annual totals on line 11, or month by month on lines 12 through 23. Some situations force the monthly lines, and the 1095-A was entered with annual totals only. On our test return, adding a shared policy allocation is what forced it. A second 1095-A entry holding only an annual advance payment amount set it off too.
How to clear it. On the Form 1095-A screen, Coverage Information (Part III), enter lines 21 (January) through 32 (December) in all three columns: premium, SLCSP and advance payment, copied from the client's 1095-A. Then clear the line 33 annual totals row. If a stray second 1095-A entry is the cause, delete it.
Ref 50245: shared policy allocation with no monthly premiums
Form 8962: Form 1095-A - Health Insurance Marketplace Statement - Monthly premium amounts in the Coverage Information (Part III) section must be present if entries are made for Shared Policy Allocation (Form 8962, Part IV).
What it means. The same problem as 42308, worded for the shared policy case. It fired alongside 42308 every time.
How to clear it. Enter the monthly amounts on lines 21 through 32 of the Form 1095-A screen, as above.
Ref 42319: SLCSP or advance payment with no premium
Form 8962: Form 1095-A - Health Insurance Marketplace Statement, Part III - Household Information requires an entry for Monthly Premium in any period where there are entries for Monthly Second Lowest Cost Silver Plan (SLCSP) and/or Monthly Advance Payment of Premium Tax Credit.
What it means. A month has an SLCSP amount or an advance payment but no premium. On our test return, coverage ended in June but the SLCSP and advance payment amounts were left in for July through December.
How to clear it. Make each month match the client's 1095-A. If coverage really ended, clear the SLCSP and advance payment for the months after it ended. If coverage continued, enter the missing premiums.
Ref 41864: shared policy needs a policy number
Form 8962, Shared Policy Allocation #1: Policy Number is a required field and must be all alpha and/or numeric characters.
What it means. A shared policy allocation is entered, and the 1095-A's policy number is blank or has characters other than letters and digits. A blank policy number raised no diagnostic at all until an allocation was added.
How to clear it. On the Form 1095-A screen, Recipient Information (Part I), enter the marketplace-assigned policy number (line 2 of the 1095-A), letters and digits only.
Ref 42102: shared policy with no allocation percentage
For each shared policy allocation listed on Part 4 of Form 8962, there must be at least one percentage entered in column e (Premium Percentage), column f (SLCSP Percentage) or column g (Advance Payment of the PTC Percentage) for efile purposes. If the percentage is 0%, then enter -1.For taxpayers whose Household Income as a Percentage of Federal Poverty Line is less than 100% on Form 8962, Line 5, an entry is required for the Advance Payment of the PTC Percentage for each shared policy allocation.
What it means. A shared policy row has the other taxpayer's SSN and the months, but every percentage column is blank.
How to clear it. On the Form 1095-A screen, Shared Policy Allocation, enter the agreed split as a decimal in each percentage column (0.5 for an even split). For a 0% allocation, enter -1, not 0.
Ref 58459: the "this return will need to be paper filed" message that is usually fixable
Form 8962 Reject: For electronic filing purposes, enrollment premiums or advanced payment of PTC must be entered on Form 8962, Part II, line 11 or lines 12 through 23. Since a shared policy allocation does not include these calculations, this will cause an electronic filing reject. This return will need to be paper filed.
What it means. Nothing from the shared policy allocation is reaching Part II of Form 8962, so Part II is empty.
How to clear it. Despite the wording, we did not need to paper file. The diagnostic stayed after the monthly amounts were entered and cleared only once the allocation percentages were in (see 42102). Check those before you give up on e-file.
Ref 49480: "other taxpayer will reconcile" with no allocation
When indicating that another taxpayer will reconcile all APTC paid and this taxpayer is not taking the PTC (tax family size=0), Part IV of Form 8962 (the shared policy section) must be completed indicating the policy number, SSN of the other taxpayer, start and end months, and allocations of 0% (-1 entries) in the applicable box(es). [The message continues with where to enter each item.]
What it means. On the Premium Tax Credit screen, the box saying another taxpayer will reconcile all the APTC is checked, but Part IV is empty. The instructions allow this when the two taxpayers agree that the other one reconciles everything: this taxpayer enters zero on line 1 and completes Part IV with the policy allocated 0%.
How to clear it. If the box was checked by mistake, uncheck it. If it is right, complete the Shared Policy Allocation section of the Form 1095-A screen: the policy number, the other taxpayer's SSN, the start and end months, and -1 in each percentage column.
Ref 42094: dependents' modified AGI with no dependent
When Form 8962, line 2b, includes an amount for dependents' modified AGI, there must be at least one dependent with a social security number in the return on Form 1040 for e-file purposes.
What it means. Line 2b has an amount, but the return claims no dependent with an SSN. Line 2b is only for dependents who are required to file their own return because their income is over the filing threshold.
How to clear it. If no dependent belongs on the return, clear Dependents' modified AGI on the Premium Tax Credit screen. If one does, add them, with their SSN, under General > Dependents. Watch this one: on our test return the stray $5,000 flowed into household income and cut the credit by more than two thirds before anyone noticed.
Mistakes ProConnect does not flag
Just as useful: things we got wrong on purpose that produced no diagnostic at all. Check these yourself.
- A 1095-A with the SLCSP column blank. The credit quietly dropped to zero and only the repayment was charged. The instructions say column B can be blank or wrong, especially when no APTC was paid or a change in circumstances was not reported. The fix is to find the correct SLCSP premium, which for the federal marketplace you can look up at HealthCare.gov/Tax-Tool.
- Annual totals that disagree with the monthly amounts. No warning.
- Married filing separately with a 1095-A. The credit was disallowed without a diagnostic. That matches the rule for most married couples filing separately, but the instructions have exceptions for victims of domestic abuse and spousal abandonment, and ProConnect will not ask you about them.
- "No marketplace insurance" checked on a return that has a 1095-A. No warning about the contradiction.
Practice it on a full return
Diagnostics are easier to read once you have worked the form yourself. The marketplace premium tax credit practice return gives you a W-2 and a Form 1095-A to prepare Form 8962 from, with an answer key. The completed Form 8962 example walks through the form line by line.
FAQ
Can a return with negative household income on Form 8962 be e-filed?
Not in ProConnect. When line 2a plus line 2b is below zero, line 3 shows zero, the IRS e-file rules require line 3 to equal 2a plus 2b, and ProConnect raises ref 42135. If the loss is real, file on paper.
How do I enter 0% in a ProConnect shared policy allocation?
Enter -1. ProConnect treats a blank as "no entry" and raises ref 42102, so a true 0% allocation has to be entered as -1.
Why is the premium tax credit zero when the client had marketplace coverage?
Check the SLCSP column of the Form 1095-A first. If it is blank, the credit comes out zero and ProConnect gives no diagnostic. Also check the filing status: married filing separately usually means no credit unless an exception applies.
When does ProConnect need monthly 1095-A amounts instead of annual totals?
Whenever Form 8962 has to use lines 12 through 23, for example with a shared policy allocation. ProConnect then raises ref 42308 until the monthly amounts are entered and the annual row is cleared.