← All practice returns
#20250097IndividualAdvancedTY 2025Forms: 1040, 8606Premium

Backdoor Roth plus an IRA withdrawal: pro-rata on both

A 61-year-old engineer does a backdoor Roth with the $8,000 catch-up limit and, in the same year, takes a regular withdrawal from his pre-tax rollover IRA. Form 8606 spreads his basis over both the conversion and the withdrawal, so lines 7, 12, and 15 come into play alongside the conversion lines.

The taxpayer's facts and source documents come with this premium return, along with the answer key and the completed return. Unlock it on its own, or go Unlimited for every return.

Taxpayer facts

Who this is and what their year looked like.

Gideon is single, 61, and lives in Tampa, Florida. He manages a civil engineering group and participates in his employer's 401(k). His pay is too high to contribute to a Roth IRA directly or to deduct a traditional IRA contribution.

In January 2025 he made an $8,000 nondeductible traditional IRA contribution for 2025 and converted it to his Roth IRA two weeks later. In June he also withdrew $20,000 from a rollover IRA (pre-tax money from a former employer's 401(k)) to replace the roof on his house, and had 10% withheld. He takes the standard deduction.

Source documents

The 6 documents you will prepare the return from: W-2: Wage and Tax Statement, 1099-R: Distributions From Pensions, Annuities, Retirement or Profit-Sharing Plans, IRAs, Insurance Contracts, etc. (conversion), 1099-R: Distributions From Pensions, Annuities, Retirement or Profit-Sharing Plans, IRAs, Insurance Contracts, etc. (withdrawal), 5498: IRA Contribution Information, traditional IRA, 5498: IRA Contribution Information, rollover IRA, and 5498: IRA Contribution Information, Roth IRA.

Included when you unlock this return

Unlock it to open the taxpayer's facts, every source document, the answer key and the completed return. Or go Unlimited for every return in the library.

Objectives

What a correct return should capture.

Level: Advanced. Before you start: You're comfortable with Form 1040 and Schedules 1 to 3, and with the forms an Intermediate return uses.

Try these first (suggested, if the topics are new to you): Backdoor Roth conversion and the pro-rata rule (Advanced); Early retirement withdrawal and the penalty (Intermediate)

  • File as Single and report W-2 box 1 wages on Form 1040, line 1a.
  • Confirm the 2025 IRA limit for someone age 50 or older ($8,000) and that the contribution is fully nondeductible: he is covered by a workplace plan (W-2 box 13) and his income is above the 2025 single deduction phase-out range of $79,000 to $89,000. Report it on Form 8606, line 1, with $0 of prior basis on line 2.
  • Confirm he could not contribute to a Roth IRA directly: compare his modified AGI (which leaves out the conversion income) to the 2025 single Roth phase-out range of $150,000 to $165,000.
  • Complete Form 8606 Part I. Line 6 is the 12/31/2025 value of every traditional IRA he owns at every custodian. Line 7 is the regular withdrawal (not the conversion). Line 8 is the amount converted.
  • Work out the line 10 ratio, then split his basis: line 11 for the conversion, line 12 for the withdrawal, line 13 in total, and the basis he carries into 2026 on line 14.
  • Find the taxable part of the withdrawal on line 15c and the taxable part of the conversion on Part II, line 18. Report both 1099-Rs in total on Form 1040, line 4a, and the sum of lines 15c and 18 on line 4b.
  • Recognize that code 7 on both 1099-Rs means he was 59½ or older, so there is no 10% additional tax and no Form 5329.
  • Apply the standard deduction, compute the tax with the exact bracket formula (taxable income is over $100,000), and include the 1099-R withholding with the W-2 withholding to reach the refund or balance due.
  • Note that Florida has no state income tax, so there is no state return here.

Check your work

Unlocking this return opens the taxpayer's facts and source documents, the answer key, and the complete return, the way a real client receives it: the 1040 and its schedules, the workpapers behind every number, and the signature forms.

Stuck? Work through it with Yehuda

A one-on-one, 30-minute tutoring session on this return with Yehuda Tenenbaum, EA. Bring the spot where you got stuck and we will work through it together: how the forms connect, why a figure lands where it does, and how to check your work. $250. This is education on the practice return, not advice on your own taxes.

Book a tutoring session