โ† All practice returns
#20250107IndividualIntermediateTY 2025Forms: 1040, Sch 2, 8606, 5329, 1040-VPremium

Early Roth IRA withdrawal: contributions first, then earnings

A 36-year-old empties most of a three-year-old Roth IRA, taking out more than she ever put in. Use the Roth ordering rules on Form 8606 Part III to find the taxable earnings, then figure the additional 10% tax on Form 5329.

The taxpayer's facts and source documents come with this premium return, along with the answer key and the completed return. Unlock it on its own, or go Unlimited for every return.

Taxpayer facts

Who this is and what their year looked like.

Reina is single, 36, and lives in Laramie, Wyoming. She works full time as a dental hygienist at a family dental practice and has no dependents.

She opened a Roth IRA in 2022 and contributed to it for 2022, 2023, and 2024. In August 2025 she withdrew most of the account to pay off credit card balances. It was the first time she had ever taken money out of a Roth IRA, and she has never converted or rolled anything into one. She also has a little bank interest and takes the standard deduction.

Source documents

The 4 documents you will prepare the return from: W-2: Wage and Tax Statement, 1099-INT: Interest Income, 1099-R: Distributions From Pensions, Annuities, Retirement or Profit-Sharing Plans, IRAs, Insurance Contracts, etc., and Roth IRA records: Reina M. Tanaka, Medicine Bow Investment Services, account ending 4471.

Included when you unlock this return

Unlock it to open the taxpayer's facts, every source document, the answer key and the completed return. Or go Unlimited for every return in the library.

Objectives

What a correct return should capture.

Level: Intermediate. Before you start: You can prepare a basic Form 1040: W-2 wages, the standard deduction, and federal withholding.

Try these first (suggested, if the topics are new to you): Early retirement withdrawal and the penalty (Intermediate)

  • File as Single. Report the W-2 box 1 wages on Form 1040, line 1a (the 401(k) deferral is already left out) and the bank interest on line 2b.
  • Read the 1099-R: code J means an early distribution from a Roth IRA with no known exception, and box 2a is blank, so you have to figure the taxable amount yourself.
  • Decide whether the withdrawal is a qualified Roth distribution. Test her age and the 5-year period that starts with the first year a Roth contribution was made.
  • Complete Form 8606, Part III: the nonqualified distribution on line 19, no first-time homebuyer expenses on line 20, and her basis in regular Roth contributions on line 22. Use her contribution history to figure line 22.
  • Apply the Roth ordering rules: regular contributions come out first and are never taxed, then conversions (she has none, so line 24 is zero), then earnings. Line 25c is the taxable amount. Note that, unlike a traditional IRA, the account balance plays no part in the calculation.
  • Report the gross distribution on Form 1040, line 4a and the Form 8606, line 25c amount on line 4b.
  • Complete Form 5329, Part I: the taxable early distribution on line 1, no exception on line 2, and the additional 10% tax on line 4. Carry it to Schedule 2, line 8 and on to Form 1040, line 23.
  • Apply the 2025 single standard deduction, look up the tax in the tax tables, and reconcile the W-2 withholding (nothing was withheld from the 1099-R) to the refund or balance due. Wyoming has no state income tax.

Check your work

Unlocking this return opens the taxpayer's facts and source documents, the answer key, and the complete return, the way a real client receives it: the 1040 and its schedules, the workpapers behind every number, and the signature forms.

Stuck? Work through it with Yehuda

A one-on-one, 30-minute tutoring session on this return with Yehuda Tenenbaum, EA. Bring the spot where you got stuck and we will work through it together: how the forms connect, why a figure lands where it does, and how to check your work. $250. This is education on the practice return, not advice on your own taxes.

Book a tutoring session